Post by Deleted on Aug 27, 2013 7:32:14 GMT -5
Actually, ND, you've jumped onto the final thing I was trying to do with my posts (outside of my first).
I mentioned that I was getting a similar vibe this game with two of the players, one of them being NE. While the one with NE was wrong (since eagerness isn't really incriminating, just curious), I can't help but feel the vibe I have with Thomas isn't. So far, we have him defending Aerso early on when we started to vote against him, and then shifted votes near the end when the majority started to grow against him. It's the EXACT same thing that happened last game with NE; he defended NE last game saying that it could have just been eagerness being translated wrong (not the exact word for word, but the simple version), and then near the end suddenly started to agree with my theory and voted against NE.
Yet in this game, he even talked about lynching NE before the round even started for exhibiting the same eagerness as last game. So far we have him defending one player that turned out to be a proxy, and then condemning another pre-round that ended up being an innocent...already a bad track record.
One of the other reasons (outside of acting on the theory I had) I really pushed on the Wolfhunters bit was because I wanted to see Thomas' reaction to it as well as use Wolfhunters as a possible example. Since in my mind I believe Wolfhunters is at least a Proxy, then if Thomas defended him as well and he turned out guilty, it would assure me that Thomas was quite possibly a bad guy as well. If Wolfhunters ended up being an innocent (hence why I was counting on the Seer for one of us), then we could chalk it up to just being Thomas' tactic this game.
Since we don't have the seer's help this round, though, lynching Wolfhunters is really the only way we're going to get anywhere. As I said, I do believe there's a strong possibility that he's at least a proxy, and his death will possibly reveal the intentions of Thomas as well.
Vote: Lynch Wolfhunters
Edited note: I realize I made an error in one of my statements. Thomas didn't change his vote to Aerso because of the growing majority, he did it because ND had brought to light him being the seer's voice and only changed his vote at that instance.
I mentioned that I was getting a similar vibe this game with two of the players, one of them being NE. While the one with NE was wrong (since eagerness isn't really incriminating, just curious), I can't help but feel the vibe I have with Thomas isn't. So far, we have him defending Aerso early on when we started to vote against him, and then shifted votes near the end when the majority started to grow against him. It's the EXACT same thing that happened last game with NE; he defended NE last game saying that it could have just been eagerness being translated wrong (not the exact word for word, but the simple version), and then near the end suddenly started to agree with my theory and voted against NE.
Yet in this game, he even talked about lynching NE before the round even started for exhibiting the same eagerness as last game. So far we have him defending one player that turned out to be a proxy, and then condemning another pre-round that ended up being an innocent...already a bad track record.
One of the other reasons (outside of acting on the theory I had) I really pushed on the Wolfhunters bit was because I wanted to see Thomas' reaction to it as well as use Wolfhunters as a possible example. Since in my mind I believe Wolfhunters is at least a Proxy, then if Thomas defended him as well and he turned out guilty, it would assure me that Thomas was quite possibly a bad guy as well. If Wolfhunters ended up being an innocent (hence why I was counting on the Seer for one of us), then we could chalk it up to just being Thomas' tactic this game.
Since we don't have the seer's help this round, though, lynching Wolfhunters is really the only way we're going to get anywhere. As I said, I do believe there's a strong possibility that he's at least a proxy, and his death will possibly reveal the intentions of Thomas as well.
Vote: Lynch Wolfhunters
Edited note: I realize I made an error in one of my statements. Thomas didn't change his vote to Aerso because of the growing majority, he did it because ND had brought to light him being the seer's voice and only changed his vote at that instance.