ONE NIGHT WEREWOLF - Round 1 - Night Phase

[Benevolent Thomas]

who did you scan and what was their role?

[Tierra de Madre]

I scanned Barry, and he was a villager. So presumably that's what W&S is now.

I pm'd Barry to say I'd scanned him and that I knew he was a villager, if there is any doubt, the timestamp on that is before he publicly posted.

[Barry]

What Tierra says is totally accurate. I received a pm from her saying she was the Seer and had scanned me to be a villager - which I was. I then disclosed on the game thread that I was a villager, after BT claimed to be the other villager. After that, Ater claimed to have switched my role and W&S'....That's where we stand.

Jul 25, 2014 21:00:53 GMT -5 Tierra de Madre said:

Barry, that is terrifying. I think i want to lynch you now.

Tierra, in the USA it's illegal to lynch or execute anyone who is so mentally incompetent that he doesn't even know who or what he is! Therefore, any vote to lynch me would be unconstitutional and thereby null & void. So there.

[Tierra de Madre]

I do love that you just called yourself mentally incompetent, Barry.

It would be useful if W&S was here to give some information from that side of things.

Alright. I'm about to exit the country, so I need to put in a vote. I'm going to go with Ayunli, because every other time she's gone quiet she's been a wolf. Little else I can base it on.

LYNCH: AYUNLI

[Barry]

Tierra's gut is normally pretty accurate, except for the part about my being mentally incompetent. Only my wife knows that for sure. And even if I am, I'm certain it's only temporary for the duration of this game.

Lynch: Ayunli

[Witchcraft and Sorcery]

I'm traveling all day today and will be home tomorrow afternoon. Should have better internet situation tonight as I'm going to be in Chicago. Is it okay for me to say what my role was Firstaria?

[Tierra de Madre]

Yes, the rules say everyone is allowed to. Everyone is also allowed to lie, so we just have to decide whether we believe you or not.

[Benevolent Thomas]

Ayunli hasn't been talking which is the most important factor of this game. I have no problem voting for her at the current time.

vote: Lynch Ayunli

[Witchcraft and Sorcery]

Alright I won't have internet until very late so I'll just say that I was the robber. The role I stole was a villager. If you want to know who from I will post that tonight.

[Ayunli]

Jul 26, 2014 5:50:10 GMT -5 Tierra de Madre said:

I do love that you just called yourself mentally incompetent, Barry.

It would be useful if W&S was here to give some information from that side of things.

Alright. I'm about to exit the country, so I need to put in a vote. I'm going to go with Ayunli, because every other time she's gone quiet she's been a wolf. Little else I can base it on.

LYNCH: AYUNLI

Actually, if you ask anybody, I'm pretty much always quiet. Especially lately - I just finished campaigning for (and not winning) the HW Senate seat, and in the mean time just got really caught up in recruiting, TITO, and spamming the heck out of Taco Island. I ended up putting WW37 on the sidelines because it really confused me with the double voting (lynch/empower) system. Waaay too much to think about. And besides, as in most WW games, other people usually end up saying what I'm thinking before I even get there. It's just the way it is. So you really make me laugh on the "every other time she's gone quiet" part - there's not too many games where I haven't been quiet. Anyways, strictly for the sake of revealing my role under threatening of death, I'm a Wolf - or at least, I was. Goodness knows what I am now that all the switch-a-roos have been done...Believe me or don't, your choice.

[Tierra de Madre]

In my head, you're both always quiet, and always a wolf.

[Benevolent Thomas]

Well the robber claimed to steal a villager and the Troublemaker didn't mention you, so I think we made the right call.

[Ater Nox]

Looks like I will vote: Lynch Ayunli

[Ayunli]

Well, the other wolf has been real quiet too and hasn't drawn attention either! Oh, well, we'll see....I'll laugh if I didn't stay a wolf after all

[Barry]

None of the claimed actions by Ater as Troublemaker, W&S as Robber, nor Tierra as Seer have been disputed by anyone. Similarly, no one has come forward to claim that either myself or BT have been "less than candid" in claiming to have been the only 2 villagers originally....That leaves Ayunli and Random as the only two possible original Wolves -- neither of whose roles were claimed to have been switched by either Ater or W&S, whose possessed the only two roles that can do a switcheroo.....Therefore, our lynch vote of Ayunli  appears to be sound......The one reasonably possible fly in the ointment could be that W&S did NOT switch with a villager, as he claimed; but rather, with Ayunli, which would now make her an innocent and W&S a wolf. That would be a shrewd winning move for the wolves and W&S to make. Let's hope that's not the case and I don't think it is. I believe W&S when he says he switched with a villager.

[Ayunli]

^Ok, you just made the game sound super easy right there. Like I said, I'm just hoping for the best here! Hmph.

[Firstaria]

Well, this had been a failure.

Missing people, nothing going on, pretty much it was the exact opposite of the games I played, proving this was not the right time to try this.


At least you won. Ayunli was a WEREWOLF. Late times and lack of cooperation for missing members made this boring.
I suggest to try this with friends live, it's a lot of fun.

[Ater Nox]

I think it didn't go too bad First. It was the first game and I don't think that people really knew what to expect or do. I think that within a few games people should pick up on some strategies (wolves pretending to have switched two players roles for example) and it should become much more interesting.

[Deleted]

Jul 28, 2014 15:14:31 GMT -5 Firstaria said:

Well, this had been a failure.

Missing people, nothing going on, pretty much it was the exact opposite of the games I played, proving this was not the right time to try this.


At least you won. Ayunli was a WEREWOLF. Late times and lack of cooperation for missing members made this boring.
I suggest to try this with friends live, it's a lot of fun.

Don't be too hard on it, First. It's a first time thing, so it's bound to not garner an exceptional amount of interest at first. The more you play with it, the more you'll get more interested people. If I had seen the thread earlier, I would have signed up as well. But I didn't see it in time.

[Benevolent Thomas]

Its not your fault that I'm so great at any form of Werewolves!

Nah, but seriously, the wolves didn't even try. It was also kind of funny that the plane jane villagers were the most active. I don't know if its because we've played so much together, but I feel as if though I make a great team with most of the active players here: Barry, Tierra and Nox.

[Ayunli]

Yeah, when it came to the Wolf PM thread me and Random didn't say anything, and I knew right away that if I said I was a wolf, I'd be killed, game over. After all, someone witched with a villager, not a wolf, and all the good guys were more than happy to come forward and say who they were. Random posted once, that's it. I figured I'd just sit back and let things play out, since there was nothing I could do. Also, the good guys did somehow end up with the more active players, but oh well, stuff happens lol.

[Barry]

Firstaria, I don't think this game was a failure at all.

SPOILER: Click to show

{Spoiler}
After all, I won it for the villagers!

Seriously, I wouldn't let the first shot at a new game get you down. Just as some games of WW are better than others, and certainly different from each other, I think you've got to give it a shot or two before you give it up. I know I'd certainly give it another go.

[Firstaria]

I decided I will try again after summer in the end, but I hope there will be a lot more people then. This game shines when you pass the 10 players mark.

[Coryo]

Awww, but I just joined this game.