SC Resolution: Commend Trav khar

[Guy]

This is the discussion thread. Please go here to cast your vote.

Commend Trav khar
A resolution to recognize outstanding contribution by a nation or region.

Category: Commendation
Nominee: Trav khar
Proposed by: Austin Setzer


Description: REGOGNIZING that Trav Khar has enormous freedom within the region

SEEING that Trav Khar members are many different types of governments that are still able to live together in peace & prosper

SEEING the expensive time & effort put in by Trav Khar’s nation to better Trav Khar & the NS world

PRAISING Trav Khar for the establishment of T.H.I., Trav Kharian Historical Institute, dedicated to the gathering of Regional Histories & NS History

NOTING that without forming T.H.I. many regions Histories would likely go unrecorded & lost

PRAISING Trav Khar for the refounding of one of NationState’s Grandest & Glorious Ancient Regions; Solarius

SEEING that Trav Khar displays an Impressive amount of Unity between Trav Khar and it’s Honor Providences The International Nations & Solarius

ACCEPTING that Trav Khar has made enormous strides in trying to maintain peace throughout the world

HEREBY COMMENDING Trav Khar for the above statements

[Ananke II]

Unless someone can give me a good reason for commending them I'm voting against. It's not that long ago since the region got refounded and so far I haven't heard anything about their activity level. It used to be decent sized back in the day, but my only recollections of the place from then is 1) that there was quite some strife internally in their region and 2) that Nikovakia and Cindy1 spied on ADN and that the region pretty quickly turned anti-defender.

[Wordy]

I would love more information before I decide how to vote on this one.
I will go look at NS forum to see if there is any info there.
Would be grateful for more opinions on this one.

[Guy]

Sorry, had a broken link up there. Fixed.

Voting nay unless someone can find a really good reason why not.

[Markanite]

Don't know him, never even heard of him so I'll vote Nay

[Anime Daisuki]

PRAISING Trav Khar for the establishment of T.H.I., Trav Kharian Historical Institute, dedicated to the gathering of Regional Histories & NS History

I looked at their forum. It seems this so called Historical Institute is just a collection of stuff someone copy and pasted from the public sections of ours and a few region's regional forums.

Wysteria's
travkharv.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=nsreco&action=display&thread=48

10KI's
travkharv.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=nsreco&action=display&thread=47

NOTING that without forming T.H.I. many regions Histories would likely go unrecorded & lost

This is a laughable claim. No.

[Enigmatic]

Considering that their main point for a commendation is the THI and that is just a collection of documents collected from other regions and other active forums as Anime points, I don't see much reason for a commendation. It's good sure, but these commendations are supposed to be reflective of major work within NS. I just don't think this qualifies.

[Dinarii]

Like others, I need a reason to be swayed in favor of this particular resolution.

[Walabamba]

I'm against as well.

[Cerb]

I see no reason to commend them.

[Takaram]

Nay, for pretty much every reason mentioned.

[Strawberrry Fields]

Well for those are interested in more info. I myself believe there are many great regions within Nationstates worth being Commended, and Trav Khar is one of them. Trav Khar has like many regions has it’s own unique diverse culture and has grown with the support of devoted players. Along with re-establishing Solarius a region of History if anyone remembers them, once one of the largest defender group in NS.

Yes a number of THI Library Histories are copied from forums, I had talked with grub & he had given me a link to yours. Not all of them are though, and in some cases the only reason any History was recorded was because of THI;

travkharv.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=nsreco&action=display&thread=55

travkharv.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=nsreco&action=display&thread=63


Trav Khar's not a total stranger i've been on your forum before, signed up months ago.

I hope those who oppose might reconsider, Myself, Austin, & the Trav Kharian people have put alot of effort in this, and I hate to see it be for nothing.

[ImperialPoland]

meh, i don't see any harm in not commending them. what the hell, I'll vote for

[Echolilia]

"Commend Trav khar" was defeated 3,503 votes to 968.